Fight Club and Marxism, do you see it?

26 replies jump to bottom
Geo
Joined: 07/07/2008
User offline. Last seen 6 days 14 hours ago.

Every topic on here bores me to the extreme. So i post this question which has always tickled me abit. Was this whole movie screaming the modern evolution of modern mankind to you? It makes me wonder if he realized what he was writing. But in the ending the main character gives up his "fantasy" and turns himself in, realizing the sacrifice is to great. Was this a twist proclaiming the inescapable human virus, or was it simply a delve into the concept it (Selfless society, Utopia, Venus project) can be done if we are willing to sacrifice certain commodities but we can't be "the unfaithful". I would argue mankind is inherently evil and the end of the movie would lead to things of worse but what do you think? Do you think Chuck is a Marxist deep down in is internals, like maybe not his lungs or his kidneys but, possibly his heart or his brain?

__________________________

R.T.A.

Atomos
Slash & Burn
Atomos's picture
From: Portland, OR
Joined: 12/22/2003
User offline. Last seen 6 weeks 6 days ago.

just me being a dick, but if we bore you, why did you bother to register? also, durden and marxism? talk about boring.....

__________________________

www.triplebeard.com
http://darkroomreview.blogspot.com
“...There are so many ways of being despicable it quite makes one's head spin. But the way to be really despicable is to be contemptuous of other people's pain. You ought to have some apprehension that the man you see before you was once even younger than you are now and arrived at his present wretchedness by imperceptible degrees.”
-James Baldwin

Geo
Joined: 07/07/2008
User offline. Last seen 6 days 14 hours ago.

lol For the like minded writers. I don't care about his characters i'm trying to make a real assessment into his phycology, behind the story which made this site popular, because this marxist mindset is one i'm seeing more and more of late. And just me being a dick but i wish people gave a more of a shit about things outside of their simple concepts of enjoyment. Smile

__________________________

R.T.A.

Atomos
Slash & Burn
Atomos's picture
From: Portland, OR
Joined: 12/22/2003
User offline. Last seen 6 weeks 6 days ago.

you could argue just as easily though that tyler is a spiritual leader, much like jesus or Buddha, just as many people will disagree, but thats the fun of the conversation. and it also leads to a discussion as to whether you can even put symbolism to literature.

__________________________

www.triplebeard.com
http://darkroomreview.blogspot.com
“...There are so many ways of being despicable it quite makes one's head spin. But the way to be really despicable is to be contemptuous of other people's pain. You ought to have some apprehension that the man you see before you was once even younger than you are now and arrived at his present wretchedness by imperceptible degrees.”
-James Baldwin

Tuffy
Dipsomaniac Kiss
Tuffy's picture
From: Two Hits and a Miss
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 2 days 8 hours ago.
Geo wrote:
Every topic on here bores me to the extreme.

Nosce te ipsum.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Geo
Joined: 07/07/2008
User offline. Last seen 6 days 14 hours ago.

I don't care about his characters. That kinda supports the Chuck Palahniuk is a crazy marxist theory though, creating human characters to call for some drastic change in behavior for the benefit of creating a non-consuming, selfless planet. And some people view this as a possible vision of religious revolution. But what i wanna know is why so socialist? What's up with the we can train, beat, kill the evil out of mankind mentality? That is my question and is anyone falling/attracted to it as a reality? Is one of our favorite authors a marxist, maybe even unknown to himself. Like the queer that doesn't yet know he's a fagot.

__________________________

R.T.A.

Tuffy
Dipsomaniac Kiss
Tuffy's picture
From: Two Hits and a Miss
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 2 days 8 hours ago.

Ah.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

Giggan
Viva Voluntarisme
Giggan's picture
From: Concord, The Shire
Joined: 10/19/2006
User offline. Last seen 1 day 1 hour ago.

Durden's more anticonsumerist than anticapitalist. My professor sorta disagreed but not fully.

__________________________

"They sold you hippies grunge, hip hop, now liberty activism."

http://freeconcord.org

xec8
Godder than God
xec8's picture
From: The Pearly Gates
Joined: 04/26/2005
User offline. Last seen 4 hours 17 min ago.
Geo wrote:
Every topic on here bores me to the extreme. So i post this question which has always tickled me abit. Was this whole movie screaming the modern evolution of modern mankind to you? It makes me wonder if he realized what he was writing. But in the ending the main character gives up his "fantasy" and turns himself in, realizing the sacrifice is to great. Was this a twist proclaiming the inescapable human virus, or was it simply a delve into the concept it (Selfless society, Utopia, Venus project) can be done if we are willing to sacrifice certain commodities but we can't be "the unfaithful". I would argue mankind is inherently evil and the end of the movie would lead to things of worse but what do you think? Do you think Chuck is a Marxist deep down in is internals, like maybe not his lungs or his kidneys but, possibly his heart or his brain?

You are incapable of coherent argumentation. Therefore you have no argument. I hereby dub thee a terrorist.
__________________________

thanks for sharing.blackhawk tactical pants.
— Spambot

"I could have done worse!" exultantly cried the murderer Lebret, sentenced at Rouen to hard labor for life. — Félix Fénéon

Tuffy
Dipsomaniac Kiss
Tuffy's picture
From: Two Hits and a Miss
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 2 days 8 hours ago.

Boo-urns!

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

xec8
Godder than God
xec8's picture
From: The Pearly Gates
Joined: 04/26/2005
User offline. Last seen 4 hours 17 min ago.

Burn it!

__________________________

thanks for sharing.blackhawk tactical pants.
— Spambot

"I could have done worse!" exultantly cried the murderer Lebret, sentenced at Rouen to hard labor for life. — Félix Fénéon

ScribblingDes
Fuck Pants
ScribblingDes's picture
From: louisiana
Joined: 02/16/2007
User offline. Last seen 6 weeks 14 hours ago.

I like two things about this guy.

1) instead of citing Fight Club the book, he refers to the movie.

2) the way he spelled psychology. (phycology) Unless he actually is referring to the study of algae.

__________________________

"after feeling under the weather a few days one time I went to check my symptoms online. web MD informed me I had Scarlet Fever." -Cam Cam

"I think I got hit on too. An 80-year-old woman said my glasses are very attractive. I told her that hers were pretty nice too.". -Steve

"Bloke came home from work and I'm still in my nightie. I call that a successful day off." --Sarah

xec8
Godder than God
xec8's picture
From: The Pearly Gates
Joined: 04/26/2005
User offline. Last seen 4 hours 17 min ago.
Geo wrote:
And just me being a dick but i wish people gave a more of a shit about things outside of their simple concepts of enjoyment. :)

Burn it!
__________________________

thanks for sharing.blackhawk tactical pants.
— Spambot

"I could have done worse!" exultantly cried the murderer Lebret, sentenced at Rouen to hard labor for life. — Félix Fénéon

Jacks_Username
Jacks_Username's picture
From: Some pub
Joined: 03/19/2011
User offline. Last seen 7 weeks 5 days ago.

It is in the fight club movie section.
I think fight club (the book) is kind of like Nietzsche's books, interesting commentary but not to be taken too seriously.

xec8
Godder than God
xec8's picture
From: The Pearly Gates
Joined: 04/26/2005
User offline. Last seen 4 hours 17 min ago.
Jacks_Username wrote:
It is in the fight club movie section.
I think fight club (the book) is kind of like Nietzsche's books, interesting commentary but not to be taken too seriously.

Oh, look! An expert on Nietzsche!
__________________________

thanks for sharing.blackhawk tactical pants.
— Spambot

"I could have done worse!" exultantly cried the murderer Lebret, sentenced at Rouen to hard labor for life. — Félix Fénéon

nathaniel parker
Sprung
nathaniel parker's picture
From: Outer spiral arm of Milky Way
Joined: 06/24/2005
User offline. Last seen 1 week 2 hours ago.

and the end of the movie would lead to things of worse

huh wha?

Jacks_Username
Jacks_Username's picture
From: Some pub
Joined: 03/19/2011
User offline. Last seen 7 weeks 5 days ago.
xec8 wrote:
Jacks_Username wrote:
It is in the fight club movie section.
I think fight club (the book) is kind of like Nietzsche's books, interesting commentary but not to be taken too seriously.

Oh, look! An expert on Nietzsche!

You caught me name dropping. I'm just saying people shouldn't take any book too seriously...unless its George Orwell or Don DeLillo. name drop, name drop, name dropping!

brandon.tietz
enemigo de arco
brandon.tietz's picture
From: #2 Pershing Sq.
Joined: 05/31/2009
User offline. Last seen 1 week 2 days ago.
Jacks_Username wrote:
xec8 wrote:
Jacks_Username wrote:
It is in the fight club movie section.
I think fight club (the book) is kind of like Nietzsche's books, interesting commentary but not to be taken too seriously.

Oh, look! An expert on Nietzsche!

You caught me name dropping. I'm just saying people shouldn't take any book too seriously...unless its George Orwell or Don DeLillo. name drop, name drop, name dropping!

Bark! Moo! Oink!

Walt Whitman.

__________________________

Photobucket

Jacks_Username
Jacks_Username's picture
From: Some pub
Joined: 03/19/2011
User offline. Last seen 7 weeks 5 days ago.

Aldous Huxley

Geo
Joined: 07/07/2008
User offline. Last seen 6 days 14 hours ago.

Interesting.

__________________________

R.T.A.

xec8
Godder than God
xec8's picture
From: The Pearly Gates
Joined: 04/26/2005
User offline. Last seen 4 hours 17 min ago.
brandon.tietz wrote:
Jacks_Username wrote:
xec8 wrote:
Jacks_Username wrote:
It is in the fight club movie section.
I think fight club (the book) is kind of like Nietzsche's books, interesting commentary but not to be taken too seriously.

Oh, look! An expert on Nietzsche!

You caught me name dropping. I'm just saying people shouldn't take any book too seriously...unless its George Orwell or Don DeLillo. name drop, name drop, name dropping!

Bark! Moo! Oink!

Walt Whitman.


Yelp! Coo! Purr!

Martha Stewart.

__________________________

thanks for sharing.blackhawk tactical pants.
— Spambot

"I could have done worse!" exultantly cried the murderer Lebret, sentenced at Rouen to hard labor for life. — Félix Fénéon

ScribblingDes
Fuck Pants
ScribblingDes's picture
From: louisiana
Joined: 02/16/2007
User offline. Last seen 6 weeks 14 hours ago.
Jacks_Username wrote:
It is in the fight club movie section.
I think fight club (the book) is kind of like Nietzsche's books, interesting commentary but not to be taken too seriously.

I was assuming its in the movie section because he's referring to the movie... not the other way around.

__________________________

"after feeling under the weather a few days one time I went to check my symptoms online. web MD informed me I had Scarlet Fever." -Cam Cam

"I think I got hit on too. An 80-year-old woman said my glasses are very attractive. I told her that hers were pretty nice too.". -Steve

"Bloke came home from work and I'm still in my nightie. I call that a successful day off." --Sarah

Tuffy
Dipsomaniac Kiss
Tuffy's picture
From: Two Hits and a Miss
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 2 days 8 hours ago.

This one?

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

ScribblingDes
Fuck Pants
ScribblingDes's picture
From: louisiana
Joined: 02/16/2007
User offline. Last seen 6 weeks 14 hours ago.

no, the one with Keith in the name, you tool.

__________________________

"after feeling under the weather a few days one time I went to check my symptoms online. web MD informed me I had Scarlet Fever." -Cam Cam

"I think I got hit on too. An 80-year-old woman said my glasses are very attractive. I told her that hers were pretty nice too.". -Steve

"Bloke came home from work and I'm still in my nightie. I call that a successful day off." --Sarah

Jacks_Username
Jacks_Username's picture
From: Some pub
Joined: 03/19/2011
User offline. Last seen 7 weeks 5 days ago.

Sad

Tuffy
Dipsomaniac Kiss
Tuffy's picture
From: Two Hits and a Miss
Joined: 03/29/2009
User offline. Last seen 2 days 8 hours ago.
ScribblingDes wrote:
no, the one with Keith in the name, you tool.

Whoa. Dejavu.

Also, she just shows up as Asspirating Writer on my screen.

__________________________

"Tuffy, you're a Dalek, but only because you're only being kept alive by metal, science and hatred." - ScubaSteve1729

ScribblingDes
Fuck Pants
ScribblingDes's picture
From: louisiana
Joined: 02/16/2007
User offline. Last seen 6 weeks 14 hours ago.
Tuffy wrote:
ScribblingDes wrote:
no, the one with Keith in the name, you tool.

Whoa. Dejavu.

Also, she just shows up as Asspirating Writer on my screen.

check out when its quoted.

__________________________

"after feeling under the weather a few days one time I went to check my symptoms online. web MD informed me I had Scarlet Fever." -Cam Cam

"I think I got hit on too. An 80-year-old woman said my glasses are very attractive. I told her that hers were pretty nice too.". -Steve

"Bloke came home from work and I'm still in my nightie. I call that a successful day off." --Sarah